0:01Well, welcome to Free Speech Friday.
0:04Today is Friday, October 17th, and we are about to cover the history of Israeli propaganda in America. And in doing so, we're going to talk a lot about propaganda in general and about where the money flows. um the whole purpose of propaganda, the actual tactics that get used and the evolution of the Israeli propaganda campaign specifically because it is shall we say flaring up in a big way in an unprecedented way that um stands to change the nature of American democracy honestly. Um people like my detractors all the time say, "Ian, why are you so obsessed with Israel?" Ian, why are you only talking about the
0:47genocide in Gaza? There's a genocide in Sudan. There's genocides all over the place. Why is And it's like clearly that's a propaganda tactic. But secondly, if you want an answer to that, this is why the way that the Israeli government is affecting freedom of speech in America is affecting my job directly, my ability to think and speak freely. Your ability to think and speak freely.
1:16That's not happening on behalf of anyone else. And we all know why. But the pro-Israel people like to feain ignorance and pretend like it's some great mystery or it's not even happening. And we're going to go through like 20 to 50 sources today that I would love for them to refute um and explain how it's not happening because it sure seems to be happening all the way from the office of the president down to your average regular old social media influencer. everything in between. And so, yeah, genocide is bad no matter where it happens. Yeah, what's happening in Sudan, super awful. Yeah, Muslim terrorism, Islamism,
2:04not good. Um, there's all sorts of problems in this world, and they're all worth talking about, but there is inevitably a hierarchy of problems.
2:12There are some problems that more affect my own life and my nation and my people than other problems. And because America is the sort of uh the empire that rules the world, the the body that controls more things than anyone else, things that affect America affect everybody. And things that threaten America and what makes America great threaten everybody. Um, and let's be clear, America has had some problems historically and has not really worked for the people since, you know, let's say for at least a hundred years, if not a lot more. But at least the ideals of America, the the principles that America
2:57is built on, those are still baked into all of our minds. They're baked into our spirit. They're baked into the nature of patriotism in America. They're a fundamental piece of what makes all Americans Americans. And American leadership has to play by a certain set of like um at least theoretical guidelines if not you know ideological rules because of that set of principles because of the freedom that this nation was founded on. And even if we don't actually have all the freedoms that we were told that we would have, the idea of those freedoms is still powerful and needs defending because if that idea
3:35slips away, if it's changed a little by little, everything slides out from under.
3:44So, we're going to start with a few clips from a documentary that I always tell people to watch, that I always cite um and send people to if they're new to this issue, if they're new to the Israel Palestine conversation, if they're new to the history of Israel um because you can't really understand the nature of the situation if you don't understand the nature of the conversation.
4:18As in, if you're receiving a bunch of information and half of it is propaganda, you need to know what is propaganda. You need to know what is a trustworthy source and what is not a trustworthy source. You need to know what are the biases in this space. You need to know who has vested interest in, you know, telling you their own version of the truth. Okay?
4:44And this is the best way to get started understanding it, >> guys. And >> none of this is by accident. It's the result of a deliberate effort to shape American perceptions of the conflict, a propaganda effort that really begins to take shape with Israel's invasion of Lebanon in 1982.
5:02Um, I also I need to point out that this film has some graphic images of dead civilians that I think will probably mess up the monetization on the stream and on the YouTube. Might get the video taken down. So, I'm probably going to slide it off screen during those parts and keep the audio rolling. Um, and hopefully we won't get the stream uh taken down.
5:31Israel unleashed another massive air attack on Palestinian and it's probably going to happen in Lebanon today.
5:37>> From the sky, the howl of Israeli jets, bombing and bombing.
5:43>> Tonight, Israel has never been closer to nor more in control of an Arab capital.
5:48>> In the summer [music] of 1982, Israel invaded neighboring Lebanon in an attempt to drive the Palestinian Liberation Organization out of its encampments on the southern border with Israel. Israeli.
5:58>> So, we're starting in 1982. If you didn't hear that clearly, >> the officials justified the attack as a defensive action required to take out terrorists. But as the story played out on American television, a different narrative began to emerge. One that presented Israel as the aggressor.
6:15>> What in the world is going on? Israel's security problem on its border is 50 mi to the south. What's an Israeli army doing here in Beirut? The answer is that we are now dealing with an imperial Israel which is solving its [music] problems in someone else's country.
6:31World opinion be damned.
6:32>> The Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982 was a watershed. It was Israel breaking out beyond its immediate region to aggressively attack another country. And it was [music] a bit of a shock to many people.
6:51by the >> Israel was always that gallant little underdog democracy fighting for survival against all the odds. Now the Israelis have enexed East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights settle down more or less permanently on the West Bank and occupied close to half of Lebanon. In the interests of self-defense, that gallant little underdog, Israel has suddenly started behaving like the neighborhood bully.
7:18So that is a major theme to this whole idea is this perception of Israel as the underdog, as being surrounded by enemies at all gates, as being the victim, for lack of a better term. And I mean, it's important to remind yourself of context that today in 2025, we have a whole different set of context. But at the beginning, we didn't have the internet. We didn't have cell phones. We didn't even have very much television. There was television, but it was far more limited.
7:55The way that images were captured, the way the video was transmitted was far more limited. And so, it was much easier to control the information flowing back to the United States and around the world from this, you know, tiny little conflict in Israel. So the reporting was much much more controlled up until this conflict in 1982.
8:12That changed everything.
8:14>> By the time the war was over, the Israeli military would kill [music] 17,000 Lebanese and Palestinians and wound another 30,000, almost all of them civilians.
8:24>> In West Beirut, hospitals are so taxed with the injured that they have become specialized. This center takes only burn victims of phosphorous shells. Travel cases, concussions, and fractures are directed to other facilities.
8:37And just a few months later, American media coverage would take an even darker turn.
8:41>> There's been another horrendous turn of events in the Middle East. Hundreds of men, women, and children, perhaps as many as a thousand people in all, have been massacred in two Palestinian refugee camps in West Beirut.
8:53>> Israel's Lebanese allies, operating with the consent of the Israeli government, had massacred several thousand Palestinian [music] civilians in the refugee camps of Sabra and Chhatila, and American news media had the pictures to prove it. After the Israelis secured, >> the Israelis permitted an armored column of right-wing Christian gunmen to enter West Beirut late Friday. They took up positions surrounding Chhatila refugee camp last night and this morning they were gone. A >> bloody massacre which has heightened tensions [music] between the US and Israel.
9:20>> Sabra Shhatila was hardly the first massacre committed by Israel against Palestinians and [music] against Arabs.
9:26There's a dirty legacy of Israeli massacres from the [music] pre-state through the creation of the state and beyond. The big difference was this one [music] was televised.
9:36>> By all appearances, groups of men had been ordered to stand against the wall.
9:40>> Just want to point out too that it's a real shame, journalistically speaking, that I have to censor this, that I will probably get this video demonetized or taken down for showing this as it is official reporting of an actual set of massacres that actually happened. That, you know, is every bit as real as any other war documentary on the internet right now. every bit as real as the footage coming back from Israel and Gaza right now [snorts] >> and then gunned down in cold blood.
10:12>> Today, Palestinians searched frantically for relatives.
10:16>> They took our children, one said, "They're killing our families."
10:20>> This was a gamecher in terms of how Israel was going to deal with the question of publicity. [music] They went on the offensive for the first time. All the direct or implicit accusations that the IDF bear any blame whatsoever for this human tragedy in the Chhatila camp are entirely baseless and without any foundation.
10:41The government of Israel rejects them with a contempt which they deserve. It was perhaps the first time they recognized at the highest levels inside Israel how much they needed to do that if [music] they expected to maintain the kind of understood [music] support in the United States. Israel can do no wrong. Israel is always the the victim.
11:02Israel is the little David against the big bad Goliath.
11:062 years after the Lebanon invasion, the American Jewish Congress sponsored a [music] conference in Jerusalem to devise a formal public relations strategy known in Hebrew as Hasbra.
11:18Participants included PR and advertising executives, media specialists, journalists, and leaders of major Jewish groups. According to a brochure from the Congress, no single event brought home the need for a more effective Hasper or information program more persuasively than the 1982 war in Lebanon and the events that followed. As one conference participant put it, "Israel is no longer perceived to be little David, but Goliath steamrolling across the map."
11:47The primary aim of the conference was to develop strategies to spin unpopular Israeli policies and to counter negative press coverage by shaping the media frame in advance.
11:58News doesn't just jump into a camera. A conference delegate said it's directed.
12:02It's managed. It's made [music] accessible.
12:05Israelbased advertising executive Martin Fenton would put it in even more blunt terms. Propaganda is not a dirty word.
12:13He said, "Face it. We are in the game of changing people's minds, of making them think differently. To accomplish that, we need [music] propaganda."
12:24Right?
12:26So that is the beginning of the modern Hosbah campaign of Israel targeting America and American minds, American perception as a primary objective of their military goals, of their warfare.
12:51And we will get to Benjamin Netanyahu's more recent statements about that idea.
13:01Um, this document from the American Jewish Congress in 1984 was extremely hard to track down.
13:14Um, but I did track it down eventually and it's pretty interesting. and it goes into a lot of depth and I would highly recommend all of y'all go read it. And I think what I'm going to do is after this stream is over, I'm going to fill the description with links to several of these sources that are a little harder to find, such as this original document from the American Jewish Congress about Hosbor, as well as this more recent one, the Israel Project's 2009 Global Language Dictionary, among others.
13:43This campaign has evolved over the years um to keep pace with technology, to keep pace with sentiment and various news cycles and the broader Israeli government and strategy.
13:58But at the beginning, the choice of Carl Spielval is very significant.
14:05Um he is a famous adman that was specifically known for image inversion and in the documentary they give the example of the uh Miller light campaign I think it was where they he helped transform the image of this beer from a ladies beer to like a manly beer.
14:25[snorts] Um he said Spielval's talent, he didn't say this, this is off Wikipedia. Spielval's talents in the marketing industry were instrumental in helping to recover Israel's public image after the Lebanon war. Later in life, he would refer to his efforts as developing into a personal cause celeb, meaning like his thing. Okay.
14:50I also thought it was interesting that in his political career on Wikipedia they say that in 1995 he was appointed by President Bill Clinton and approved by the US Senate to the US Broadcasting Board of Governors which is responsible for Voice of America, Radio Free Europe, Voice of Asia, Radio Marty, WorldNet and other non-military voices of the United States government.
15:11That's called spook propaganda. Um that's the CIA, right? um that that came up during the Tucker Carlson conversations.
15:21So, let's talk about this more recent incarnation of this idea, the 2009 Global Language Dictionary. This is a um a revitalization of the idea because Israel was engaged in a whole bunch of new bombing campaigns. Um, this is around the time of Operation Castled and sentiment was not doing great. Obama had been elected in 2008.
15:51Um, television had come a long way. It was a lot easier to capture video and to spread information. Social media wasn't here yet, but it was about to hit. And they hired a new adman. At first, it was Carl Spielval. This time it was Frank Luntz, which is he's a whole other rabbit hole. Um, and there's all kinds of interesting stuff in this global language dictionary that uh I'll pull up the actual document here for you. I grabbed a few screens out of it.
16:29It is 116 pages long and it's got settle it's got chap or chapters about all sorts of you know touchy topics like page 62 is about settlements.
16:46Let's just go and peep that one real quick because the settlements are controversial to say the least.
16:57The settlements are the single toughest issue for Israel and the hostility towards them and towards Israeli policy that appears to encourage settlement activity is clearly evident. Unless and until Israeli government policy changes, here's the best communication approach because the settlements are illegal. And so, how are you going to win this campaign?
17:18How are you going to talk about this?
17:22And they have all of these strategies.
17:25talk about a willingness to negotiate and Camp David in the same sentence as in we're willing to negotiate the deal that the entire world says that we should adopt, but we're not actually going to adopt it. We're just going to talk about a willingness to negotiate.
17:39Um provide specific examples of how Israel has already sacrificed in the name of peace.
17:44Three previous Israeli leaders have demonstrated a willingness to address the settlement issue, but still the settlements continue to this day. By the way, the settlements are necessary for the security of Israel. Right. Yes.
17:57Okay.
17:59Where possible, make the settlement issue about the larger challenge of achieving a peaceful solution where Arabs and Israelis live peacefully side by side because we all know that that is the goal, right? So they have all of these uh tips, talking points, emphasize solutions wherein nobody has to leave their own homes except for the Palestinians obviously that you know are living where they need to put a settlement stress mutuality in the issue of settlements and refugees because it's totally both people's fault and both people's responsibilities. Um so they go through all the arguments, they break it
18:32down, words that do work, words that do not work. Um, those who think that the conflict is driven by an Israeli desire to hold on to territories are totally wrong. This may be a perception that some seek to promote, but it's not our reality. It's not our policy. And they're saying that those words don't work because actually what they do is they draw attention to the fact that Israel is taking land, right? And I guess I'll hop back to Obsidian because I got a screenshot of this. And there's this phrase in here that is kind of sums the whole thing up.
19:08The this is a suggestion of what's good, what does work, how you should do Hosbra. The fight is over ideology, not land, terror, not territory. It's not about Israel wanting all the land for themselves. It's not about Israel settling on Palestinian land in direct conflict with the international agreements and the peace deals that have been put in place prior. It's not about any of that. It's about terrorism. It's about stopping Islamicism and all these radical Islamic terrorists that are going to come to your town and kill you and your kids and your wives, right?
19:48Some of these talking points are still recycling to this day.
19:53Some of them have evolved a lot, right?
19:55because this whole document is tailored specifically to the Iraq war era, to the Obama presidency, to a preocial media age that was digital, but not, you know, modern digital. And there's this section that I pulled out just just to highlight that I'll make bigger for you guys. Um, chapter 2, a glossery of words that work. And when you read through it, you start to notice trends that persist to this day that knowingly or unknowingly, Zionist chills still use these same talking points. Not all of them, but a lot of them. Like the rockets, humanized rockets paint a vivid picture of what life is like in Israeli communities that
20:41are vulnerable to attack. Yes, cite the number of rocket attacks that have occurred, but immediately follow that up with what is with what it is like to make the nightly trek to the bomb shelter.
20:52And we've all seen that. We've all heard that rockets raining down, right?
20:57The right to. This is a stronger phrase than deserves. Use the phrase frequently, including the rights that both Israelis and Arabs enjoy in Israel.
21:06the right to peace that Israelis and Palestinians are entitled to and Israel's right to defend its civilians against rocket attacks, right?
21:14We're all in this together. We have all made mistakes working towards a solution. I mean, you read this document and you can basically go out and become Benjamin Netanyahu tomorrow. Okay, so I lay all that out just to highlight that this is a long campaign. This has been going on for decades, right? We're at more than 40 years now since this whole campaign was first initiated. And there's all sorts of history wrapped up in that timeline. Um, and I want to highlight just one or two other little pieces of that history because this part is super funny.
22:04denters and call it defense.
22:07>> As news media have proliferated over the years, Israel's public relations efforts have only become more and more explicit and intense.
22:25In the United States, we have a show called The Apprentice, where Donald Trump auditions people to work in his corporate boardroom. In Israel, the version of The Apprentice is called uh The Ambassador.
22:36>> The Ambassador. In a world where the real battles take place in newsrooms and TV studios, the ability to create a positive image for your country is a crucial task for every ambassador. It's a show where Israelis compete for who can offer the best haz. That means explain in Hebrew, explain our situation.
22:55>> While The Apprentice tests contestants ability to sell lemonade on the street, >> lemonade >> or handle office politics, the ambassador finalists have learned that selling real politics is a lot harder.
23:07>> The problem is that when you sell lemonade, nobody hates lemonade.
23:11Nobody's going to say that your lemonade occupies territories or that your lemonade kills babies.
23:17>> Israel's mechanism of projecting its propaganda or what they call hazbara is one of the most sophisticated arms of its government. It's a weapon of Israeli warfare.
23:28>> And when you look today at how the media cover the conflict, you see just how successful Israel's propaganda has been in reversing the legacy of Lebanon. If there's any complaints uh and there should be about civilian deaths that they they belong the responsibility and the blame belongs in one place.
23:45>> Hamas I don't >> Hamas. Um I >> think anyone should get that wrong.
23:49>> The Israeli >> shout out to baby Max Blumenthal. Bro's been killing it for a minute now.
23:55Um and then I want to show you one other little clip here just you know in honor of BB Netanyahu's wonderful face. I just wanted toh show one other little clip here. territories.
24:08>> Just listen to Netanyahu talking in private to his right-wing settler base in 2001 about how he has no intention, despite what Israel agreed to at Oslo, of giving up land and ending its illegal settlement expansion in the West Bank and the rest of the Jordan Valley.
24:50Netanyao is clear that Israel's not giving anything up. But he's also very clear that the way to make that argument is to invoke security threats. And he's especially confident that he can manipulate the American people to buy into this argument.
25:13I know what America is. America is a thing that you can move very easily.
25:19Move it in the right direction.
25:21That's a quote from BB Netanyahu.
25:25>> And this, of course, is exactly the case is made to the American people time and time again whenever Israel's been called out for refusing to end the occupation and its settlement project. We're willing to make great concessions for peace, [snorts] but there is something that I will never compromise on, and that's Israel's security. Right? All phrasing and framing straight out of the Hosbah manuals. Benjamin Netanyahu is an absolute master of hosah. The conventional wisdom is that continuing the occupation makes Israel [music] more secure. And if you buy that argument, then it's a license to occupy
26:10indefinitely. What we're >> right, a license to occupy indefinitely.
26:18And here we are, 2025 still going on.
26:24So there is a long history behind Hosbra and Hosbra is not some conspiracy theory. It is a fully funded official part of the Israeli government, of the Israeli military, of Israeli politics and Israeli life and culture. And we're about to go through all these facets, just some of many. I'm sure there's a lot more out there.
26:53that paint the picture of what it's doing today because oh boy has it evolved to meet the digital age.
27:02And I want to before we um before we dive into the actual evidence, I want to show you where this is all coming from.
27:14Credit where credit is due.
27:18Um, a lot of what we're going to talk about tonight is based upon reporting by Gen XGirl. Um, and [snorts] where are your articles, Gen Xirl? And this article in specific, Israel's coordinated campaign to propagandize conservatives in America. Incredible article um that is filled with sources and links and explanations and timelines. a dated timeline that leads from 2018 or so through to today. Okay? And we'll come back to her actual thread throughout this, too. But I've grabbed pieces of her thread and filled it in with sources that she dropped into that as well as a whole bunch of other research to complement it and to fill in
28:08more pieces of the picture here and to actually illustrate and give sourcing to a lot of these claims. Okay.
28:16And you could start anywhere, right?
28:18Hence why I started all the way back in the 80s at the beginning of this concept of Hosbra. But for the purposes of today, we'll start where Gen XGirl started in 2018. Laying the legal and ideological groundwork.
28:35Years before the public facing campaign would begin, the groundwork was being laid in the shadows. The Israeli Knesset, anticipating a need for more deniable channels of influence, sought legal advice from US attorneys specializing in the Foreign Agent Registration Act, FAR. Their goal was not compliance, but circumvention to learn how to funnel money and directives without the transparent label of foreign agent, right? Stop and think about that.
29:03The Israeli Knesset anticipated a need for more deniable channels of influence back in 2018.
29:11Why would they have wanted more of that?
29:14Were they anticipating maybe some sort of thing coming up in the coming years that would be a reason why they would need more influence in America that was obscured and opaque and hard to trace, right? So, let's not just leave it at, you know, Gen Xirl summary here. Let's look at some sources.
29:38This is an Israeli source. Um, oh no, sorry, this is not. This is the Guardian um, from August of 2024. Israel feared legal troubles over US advocacy efforts.
29:49Leaked files suggest the Israeli government sought legal advice on a US federal law requiring the disclosure of foreign backed lobbying campaigns out of concern that mounting enforcement of the law could ensnare American groups working in coordination with Israeli government. leaked documents reviewed by the Guardian suggest. Okay, so that's all the way back in 2018. They were starting to think, how do we skirt around this whole FAR issue? How do we lobby America, propagandize America without tripping the switch that will get anyone into legal trouble around foreign registration?
30:27You know, that one thing that Apac is not done and does not intend to do.
30:36November of 2023, Amachai Chikley, Israel's Minister of Diaspora Affairs, briefs Knesset lawmakers on the growing problem of anti-war protests among young Americans, particularly on elite university campuses. Chickley's solution was to go on the offensive. He launched a targeted push to counter critics, a blueprint that would define the next two years. To boost online support for Israel, target advocacy for Palestinians, crush student protest to divest from Israel on US college campuses, and to codify the IH definition of anti-semitism into US law at every level of government.
31:13Israeli documents show expansive government efforts to shape US discourse around Gaza war. This is from 2024, The Guardian. exclusive. As the Gaza war rages, Israeli funds target US college campuses and push to redefine anti-semitism in US law.
31:35We're going to talk about that definition of anti-semitism in just a second because it is extremely relevant.
31:42But throughout this whole conversation, I want to remember remind us of what is considered anti-semitic. What is a no no to talk about? And one of the biggest no- nos to talk about is this idea that there's an Israeli conspiracy, that there's some sort of Jewish conspiracy of people working together on behalf of Israel or Jewishness or whatever it is, right? That is so anti-semitic to ever say because you must hate Jews. You must you must want another Holocaust, which is not what is being said at all. What's being said is that there are massive networks of complex financial institutions, government institutions, media
32:27organizations that are working in concert, often nefariously, often regardless of the truth to propagandize, manipulate, coers, and direct policy in America.
32:42So just think about this this anti-semitic conspiracy that there's like remember conspiracy means people working together. It doesn't mean like secret assassination plots by the Illuminati with like magical bullets and psies and MK Ultra. That's not what conspiracy means. That's just a conspiracy theory, you know, as it's been dubbed. Conspiracy just means people working together, right? And so a conspiracy theory is thinking that I maybe see evidence of people working together to achieve something. And sometimes that's perfectly legit.
33:14Businesses are allowed to work together to try to win at capitalism, right?
33:18Politicians are allowed to conspire to try to win the election legally, you know, as long as they follow the law.
33:25Conspiracies just become a problem when they're breaking the law or they're nefarious or they're like kind of in that gray area or they're lying about what they're actually doing and being deceptive. things like that, you know.
33:36So, just keep that in mind. This is from the Guardian article 2020 uh4. Seconds after a smoke alarm subsided during the hearing, Chickley assured the lawmakers that there was new money in the budget for a pushback campaign, which was separate from the more traditional public relations and paid advertising content produced by the government. It included 80 programs already underway for advocacy efforts to be done in the concert way, he said. The concert remark referred to a sprawling relaunch of a controversial Israeli government program initially known as Kella Schlommo designed to carry out what Israel called mass
34:14consciousness activities targeted largely at the US and Europe.
34:19Mass consciousness activities targeted at is at the US and Europe.
34:28Interesting wording.
34:30Concert, now known as Voices of Israel, previously worked with groups spearheading a campaign to pass so-called antibi state laws that penalize Americans for engaging in boycots.
34:39Okay. Another group, Cyberwell, a pro-Israel anti-disinformation group led by former anti-disinformation group led by former Israeli military intelligence and voices officials, has established itself as an official trusted partner to Tik Tok and Meta, helping both social platforms screen and edit content. A recent cyber well report called for Meta to suppress the popular slogan, from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free. Remember, this is back in 2024.
35:05So, we're getting into this time frame here where a lot of the reporting that we're going to read is actually going to be painting in the picture behind a lot of the things that we all lived through.
35:14I was on TikTok at that time. I remember when the phrase from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free was banned.
35:21This is around the time when people started using the watermelon emoji. And this is the group, Cyberwell, a pro-Israel anti-disinformation group led by former Israeli military intelligence.
35:33They are the ones behind it, among others, right?
35:39But to be clear, Cyberwell receives no government funding whatsoever from any country, and the organization's leadership is neither affiliated with nor compensated by Voices for Israel.
35:50Right. I'm sure they are not actually funded by them.
35:55all sorts of other ways to do these things. So, [snorts] moving into 2024 here, October 7th, 2024, the ideological justification for silencing critics of Israel is provided by the Heritage Foundation's Project Esther. This document which derives its data from Israeli funded and managed NOS's like Canary Mission, NCRI, ISGAP and the ADL creates a roadmap for redefining political criticism of Israel as anti-semitism and ultimately as a form of terrorism to be criminalized. While this road map was initially used on student protesters, it would also be used to silence conservatives. Right?
36:34[snorts] So, just to be clear about what we're talking about here, we're talking about a campaign to turn criticism of Israel into terrorism. You're a terrorist for criticizing Israel because you must hate Jews. And if you hate Jews, you're a Nazi. And if you're a Nazi, well, then you're like as bad as Osama bin Laden. You should probably have no rights, not be allowed to speak, and be locked up, right?
37:04Um, I don't think we're going to go into the actual documents on Project Esther tonight.
37:13This is an interesting one. I don't even know what to make of this one. Little side note here before we get into the working definition of anti-semitism.
37:19This is an Israeli news source. New petition challenging Israel's secret information warfare campaign. Israel's government is outsourcing mass consciousness activities to private organizations unaccountable to the public.
37:33A petition submitted on Monday by attorney Sachar Ben Mayor ch charges that the Ministry of Strategic Affairs is carrying out a global propaganda campaign on behalf of the Israeli government that violates human rights and is acting without authority to do so. That's awfully anti-semitic of them to say, "Oh my goodness, that is a blood liel right there." Um, a global propaganda campaign on behalf of the Israeli government that violates human rights.
38:01>> [snorts] >> Damn, dude. This must be Hamas propaganda, eh? Um, the Ministry has been at the center of a series of articles published by the Seventh Eye over the past several months. The articles revealed that one of the Ministry of Strategic Affairs's main activities is the funding and publication of government propaganda on social networks and in newspapers, which is often carried out with the help of private businesses and nonprofit organizations operating in Israel and abroad, almost like a global conspiracy working on behalf of the Zionist state.
38:32rad. The term mass consciousness activities is just so good.
38:40Um, wait a minute. I want to get to the working definition of anti-semitism before we get too far ahead of here.
38:46Okay, we're coming to it. We're coming to it.
38:49[snorts] Israel has spent millions trying to win hearts and minds abroad. It's about to spend 20 times more. Remember, follow the money. You might find some truth.
39:01Israel's foreign ministry will receive $150 million for what's officially known as public diplomacy or in Hebrew Hazbborah. Israel's new foreign minister, Gideon Sar, in a photo, blah blah blah. Okay, let's open that up.
39:20The proposed budget for 2025 includes a massive new allocation towards pro-Israel advocacy for efforts abroad.
39:28Under the new budget, Isra Is Israel's foreign ministry will will receive $150 million on top of what it gets for its existing activities for what's officially known as public diplomacy or Hosbbor. That sum is more than 20 times what such efforts have typically been allotted in past years. The dramatic expenditure is the result of a political deal that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu struck last month to shore up his governing coalition.
39:52politician Gideon Sar and his New Hope party agreed to rejoin the coalition in return for the funding and the appointment of Sar as Israel's foreign minister. Because if you aren't aware, Benjamin Netanyahu is currently holding together a coalition government of a whole bunch of ultra farright groups that without them he would not have been elected again and he probably would have actually faced trial for his corruption trial and he probably would be in jail by now. instead he allied with all these ultra farright super extremist groups in Israel that came together and got him elected. Okay? And this is one of those
40:28groups is my understanding. I I don't I'm not actually familiar with the New Hope party, but the way they're speaking about them, that's what it's implied.
40:34And they were threatening to leave and then they agreed to rejoin because Benjamin Netanyahu made a power deal where he said, "I'll give you this if you give me that." Right? Something that Benjamin has done a lot of.
40:47[clears throat] So 20 times the budget for Hazborah in 2024.
40:57That's the kind of gravity that this situation holds for the Israeli government. It is an existential threat.
41:04The turning of American minds, I I would almost say like the turning on of the American mind, the waking up of the American citizen is an existential threat to Israel. And if we start to examine the facts and get out of the hosbor, they're [ __ ] And so they're 20xing that budget, right? I mean, just imagine. Imagine that you run a company, you've got a couple employees and they do stuff and something comes up this year and you decide that all of a sudden you need to give 20 times the funding to that one department. 20 times. That's insane.
41:46That's completely insane, right? You run a restaurant and all of a sudden you're going to give 20 times the funding to your bar manager. The [ __ ] is he going to do with it all? Right?
41:58Not double, not 10 times, 20 times the Hosbra budget. Okay, [snorts] let's pull this back up for you guys.
42:12foreign ministry to receive massive budget for public diplomacy abroad. This is reported in the Times of Israel.
42:19Again, just reconfirming with multiple sources, 150 million, more than 20 times what such efforts have typically been allotted in past years.
42:29And again, the same report actually this is clearly this article um from Jewish Chronicle is the exact same as this one.
42:39Yeah, they're they're pulling it from JTA there. So, [snorts] Gen Xirl, I'm going to pull up this actual post so that we can watch this video.
42:50The eighth front war. The idea of this eighth front war comes from our boy Jonathan.
43:03There's an eighth front in this war.
43:06It might not be a terrestrial border that you can find on a map, but this domain is as volatile, is as violent, and is as vital to our future. The information sphere, the infosphere is the eighth front in this war.
43:26So, just in case you don't know, this man is Jonathan Greenblat. And it says right there on his card, CEO and national director of the Anti-Defamation League.
43:38And if you don't know about the Anti-Defamation League, we don't even have the beginnings of the time to go into how [ __ ] up the Anti-Defamation League is. They should be called the Defamation League. and seizing the high ground in the fight for global public opinion is a battle that's as important to the long-term war as what you've done in Lebanon and Syria.
44:04>> So he just said that seizing the upper hand in the information war is as important as the kinetic war, the actual war.
44:12>> So one of the things we have fought now a sevenfront war, we have an eighth front and that is the front and the battle for truth. some Christian influencers. Okay. He said we talked about the woke right and he said I call it the woke reich.
44:30>> That's a brilliant observation.
44:33>> Brilliant observation. What he means is that's a brilliant piece of propaganda.
44:36That's a brilliant ad homonym, right?
44:39Because that's the bread and butter of Hosbra. Not the truth, not citing your sources, not accurate journalism. Notice how none of that Hosbra manual was about how to research the truth, how to site your sources, be a good journalist, how to factcheck things. None of it. That's not what it's about. It's about propaganda.
45:01>> The woke right, because these people, you know, they're not any different from the woke left. I mean, they're they're insane. They're >> they're insane. They're lunatics and they're not any different than the woke left. Well, Benjamin, as a person that grew up around the woke left and knows them quite well, and who is now a proud member of the woke Reich, as you say, let's just say we're pretty different.
45:24And it's really not that hard to figure out. I mean, like, I walk around wearing shirts that say Patriot, carrying a gun, like eating meat with my bare hands, doing physical activity, reporting on, you know, all these conspiracy theories that are very much not from the left.
45:41>> [snorts] >> um we're very different. There is sort of a horseshoe out there, but it's it's really just like a hollow ad homonym to try to say that the woke right and the woke left have anything to do with each other. Even the term woke right is a madeup word that is actually a very woke tactic where you divide people into identity groups and make up weird little semantic games to try to say you're not allowed to say that, you're not allowed to say that, that hurts my feelings.
46:05Right? The term woke right, as far as I'm aware, was made up by uh who? James James Lindsay, right? The uh I'm not going to start attacking James Lindsay's looks, never mind. [snorts] >> But they're actually meeting on some of the things. And what we have to do is we have to secure that part of our the base of our support in the United States that is being challenged systematically. A lot of this is done with money. Money of NOS's vast money of governments faster.
46:36Okay? We have to fight back. How do we fight back our influencers? I think you should also talk to them if you have a chance to that that community. They're very important.
46:48>> And secondly, we're going to have to use the tools of battle. You know, the the weapons change over time.
46:55>> We've been through this before. We've watched this clip before. The tools of battle, right? We're going to have to use the tools of battle.
47:01>> You can't fight today with swords. That doesn't work very well. Okay? And you can't fight with the fight with cavalry.
47:07that doesn't work very well. And you have these new things, you know, like drones, things like that. I won't get into that, but we have to fight with the weapons that uh apply to the battlefields in which we're engaged. And the most important ones are the social media.
47:22>> He says it right there. It's just like out in the open. We have to use the weapons that apply to the battlefields where we're fighting. And the most important one is social media. The most important battlefield is social media.
47:35And the most important weapons are social media. And so what does that mean?
47:40That means that you are the target. You are the target of Israel's most important battlefield, most important warfare campaign and your fair game. And they're going to use all the tools of warfare that they have at their disposal to target you and to get you to support Israel. And nowhere have you heard them talk about the importance of truth, the importance of factchecking, citing sources, any of that [ __ ] because that has nothing to do with it in their minds. Because the thing is, imagine if you have social media occurring, right? And this is actually the tragic irony of this conversation becomes apparent pretty quickly as you
48:25think about it. Imagine you have all of social media and it's like a pool in front of you and we're all in there, you know, spitting memes, making jokes, you know, getting in arguments, having a good old time. Social media and no one is doing any state sponsored propaganda at all. It's just real regular old conversations in social media, right?
48:47There will be some truth going around.
48:49There will be some journalism. There will be some lies and and incorrect [ __ ] There'll be clickbait. There'll be advertising. there'll be all this [ __ ] right? But ultimately, the journalistic spaces in an open social media environment with no outside foreign influences will largely just skew towards the truth because that's what everyone's job is. That's what everyone's there to do. And you'll always get some, you know, [ __ ] that are coming in and just like click baiting. You'll always get some people that are getting things wrong. That'll happen. But for the most part, if you don't do anything to that system, it'll
49:21just skew towards the truth. And the journalists that get the most truth right will rise and be popular. And certainly there will be people that will become popular because of their gimmicks and their clickbait and all these other things. But why would you need to infuse millions of dollars of warfare strategy into the social media space, right? Unless your goal was to subvert the truth because the truth is self-apparent. It's self-evident. We report on the truth for free. Right?
49:58If it's true, you don't have to pay me to report on it. And if it's not true, you could never pay me enough to report on it. Right? And so the very admission that they are going to first treat social media like warfare and that they're going to activate all of their possible weapons to target all of you with whatever it is they're doing. That admission alone tells you that they're paying to lie to you. They're paying to change your perspective and to change the nature of truth in our public square.
50:31Right?
50:35And the most important purchase that is going on right now is class followers.
50:43>> Tik Tok.
50:45>> And if the most important thing you're doing is purchasing a social media platform in another country so that you can control what young people are seeing in another country.
50:57I'm sorry. Please explain to me how that is not uh subversive.
51:04Right. And I've been talking about that for ages. A number of us have been talking about that for ages. Tik Tok has been enemy number one. Jonathan Greenblat had some great quotes about the Tik Tok problem.
51:14>> Tik Tok number one. Number one.
51:16>> And I hope it goes through because it's >> it can be consequential.
51:20>> And the other one, what's the other one that's most important?
51:24>> X.
51:25>> X.
51:27>> Very good.
51:28>> Very good class. What a pretentious prick. Um right.
51:36So this eighth front war, the most important battlefield upon which Israel finds itself today is your social media feed. It's your Instagram, it's your Facebook, it's your Twitter, it's your Tik Tok, it's your news feeds everywhere.
51:56And they're just openly talking about it.
52:03So January of 2025, the influence campaign scores a major victory.
52:09President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14188, building on a 2019 order that adopted the IH definition of anti-semitism. This order effectively codifies into US policy certain Bible references and criticism of Israel as anti-semitism, directing the full force of the federal government to use this definition to combat so-called hate.
52:37So this is the most recent one, January 29th, 2025. Additional measures to combat anti-semitism because we needed more of that.
52:46And it's building on this older executive order 13899.
52:53And when you go to look up 13899, it is not found anymore, which I don't think is like some nefarious thing. I assume it's just that they wipe all the ones from old presidencies or something like that. I don't know. But we've got the way back machine. So I went and found it and dug it up just to, you know, remind us all of what this executive order was.
53:14And I I'm confused by this one because this is 2019 that we're talking about here, right? Um, and I thought this happened in like 2023, so maybe I'm crazy. I don't know. But in 2019, in his first term, Trump was already sucking the wall, so to speak.
53:41Section two, ensuring robust enforcement of title six. Um, in identifying evidence of discrimination based on race, color, or national origin, all executive departments and agencies charged with enforcing title 6 shall consider the following. one, the non-legally binding, working definition of anti-semitism adopted on May 26, 2016 by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, which I'm sure is just a nonpartisan independent organization that's just working for the good of the world. I'm sure they have no ties to Israel. I'm sure they're not funded by the same Jewish donors funding everybody else.
54:17I'm sure that they are just just trying to, you know, remind everybody of some important history with no other weird political uh agendas at all. Right.
54:27Right. Um so what is this non-legally binding working definition of antise-mitism? And notice how they purposefully framed it in 2016 as non-legally binding so it doesn't get too scary. And then it slowly gets walked into legally binding. um it gets put slowly, little by little by little into law, right? And at first, at first in 2019, it's just it's a guideline to help you enforce Title Six. Um and then it's like a guideline that's there to help you kick students out of college campuses when they're protesting and then, you know, one thing leads to another and you're in the Goolags.
55:06Um working definition of anti-semitism.
55:09Uh is this a page that I can scroll? It is. Cool. That's the cool thing about Obsidian is I can like I literally can put web pages in here live. So, this is an actual web page that I'm scrolling through here. Love it. So, there's all this stuff at the top of the page, but it gets really juicy when you get to these bullet points. Um, so all of these things are considered anti-semitism by this working definition that is now getting codified into law and is now actually legally binding for a lot of federal institutions. And you can actually be punished. You can be fined.
55:41You can be kicked out of institutions.
55:43You can have your visas revoked. They're even talking about having your citizenship revoked in some cases if you do any of these things. Okay, just to be clear. Calling for aiding or justifying the killing of or harming of Jews in the name of a radical ideology or an extremist view of religion. Yeah, legit.
55:59Let's not hurt people or kill them.
56:02Totally legit. making menacious, dehumanizing, demonizing or stereotypical allegations about Jews such as or or the p allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective such as but especially not limited to exclusively I can't read tonight the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media economy government or other societal institutions it's just a myth all these sources that we're going through tonight is just a myth. And in fact, it's a myth that if you even discuss, you must hate Jews. So much so that you should probably be kicked out of school, have your funding
56:45revoked, have your passport revoked, have your visa revoked. Who knows, maybe we should just throw you in prison, right? For even suggesting that there might be a world Jewish conspiracy or Jews controlling the media or something like that, because Jews can't even work together. Like literally, Jews are not capable of collaborating, right? Because that's what a conspiracy is, is people working together for their goals. Duh, right?
57:14As if Jewish people can't do that.
57:17Everyone does that. Everyone does that, right? There are Christian conspiracies, there are Muslim conspiracies, there are atheist conspiracies, there's satanic conspiracies. It This is just how people work. They work together to try to do what they want to do. And Jews are better at it than just about anyone else on the planet because Jews have a stronger sense of national identity than anyone else on the planet. You might almost say they have a monopoly on national identity in a certain way and they like to keep it that way. White people back the [ __ ] off.
57:49Um because that would be bad. To be clear, you would be a Nazi if you are a white person that was proud of being white.
57:55that just to be clear that would be you'd you'd be a Nazi. So um accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group or even for acts committed by non-Jews.
58:11Um yeah I mean that's complicated. It's fair.
58:16Denying the facts scope mechanisms eg gas chambers. So basically, no Holocaust, questioning, denial, not allowed to ask questions about the Holocaust, which makes me ask all kinds of questions about the Holocaust. I'm sorry. Like, like, [laughter] you're going to try to pass laws that tell me I can't question something, I'm immediately going to question it.
58:33Accusing the Jews as people or Israel as a state of inventing or exaggerating the Holocaust.
58:39That's illegal. Um, again, it's like I wasn't questioning it before. [snorts] um accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel or to the alleged priorities of Jews worldwide than to the interests of their own nations. Right?
58:53Just don't listen to their own [ __ ] words. Right? Like who was it? Was it Ben Shapiro that said the existence of the state of Israel is the single greatest guarantor of my loyalty to America?
59:06Was it Ted Cruz that said that he got into Congress on the explicit goal to fight for Israel? Right.
59:15He's not even Jewish. He's just a [ __ ] cuck. Like accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel.
59:23That is the most mindblowing one on this whole list as far as I'm concerned.
59:28Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination. For example, by claiming that the existence of a state of Israel is a racist endeavor. The existence of the state of Israel is a racist endeavor. It's an ethnostate. and saying that you are God's chosen people is indistinguishable from saying that the Arian race is superior. Okay.
59:47Applying double standards by requiring of Israel a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation like not murdering children, like not raping prisoners that are in your prisons, like following the law, right? Like not starving an entire population of people intentionally.
60:07double standards using the symbols and images associated with classic anti-semitism, eg claims of Jesus killing g or Jews killing Jesus or blood label to characterize Israel or Israelis drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.
60:24It's like the Nazis. I'm sorry. It is right like ethnostate doing a genocide.
60:31Yeah. Um, and then I cut off on the bottom here where they talk I mean it is in part. It's right there, but they have another one I think that's about how like basically you can't talk about the Jesus thing because that would be anti-Semitic. Um, there's number there's a number of passages in the Bible that are officially anti-semitic now because of this working definition. Um, that is not non-legally binding anymore. It is now becoming legally binding and walking its way straight into the halls of power. Okay.
61:02So, let's just be clear. You're all anti-Semitic. You're all going to hell.
61:07Um, get wrecked.
61:15February 2025.
61:18In a move of profound significance, yet little known. This is huge shout out to Gen Xirl. Don't know how she dug this one up. This one is super obscure and super significant.
61:30So February of this year, [sighs] Pam Bondi on her first day disbands the Foreign Influence Task Force, the very DOJ office responsible for enforcing FARA, the Foreign Agents Registration Act. The change specifically limits DOJ prosecutors from criminally charging those involved in public relations, work, and policy advocacy on behalf of foreign businesses and nonprofits. This deliberate incapacitation of the enforcement mechanism gave a green light to foreign influence operatives, ensuring that the Knesset's 2018 plan to skirt Farara could proceed with min minimal risk of prosecution. Remember
62:10how they were worried, Israel was worried about like what are the rules around FAR and how do we get around them and how do we do our influence campaigns without tripping up the FAR system and getting into trouble because just maybe there might be something coming up on our little plans that we might kind of need to do some foreign influence campaigns about.
62:32And it's in this memorandum from Pam Bondi, the attorney general.
62:38And it's there's a whole bunch of other points too and this is just one of them.
62:41And this is just a little thing hiding in one of these points from this memo that I guess Gen Xirl noticed or something. Um shifting resources in the National Security Division to free resources to address more pressing priorities, excuse me, and end risks of further weaponization and abuses of prosecutorial discretion. The Foreign Influence Task Force shall be disbanded.
63:06Recourse to criminal charges under the Foreign Ages Registration Act and 18 Code 951 shall be limited to instances of alleged conduct similar to more traditional espionage by foreign government actors like Jeffrey Epstein maybe like like Jeffrey Epstein like in theory theoretically just like as an example Pam with respect to FAR and 95 951 the counter intelligence and export control section including the FAR unit shall focus on civil enforcement regulatory initiatives and public guidance.
63:38So, no more FAR enforcement unless it's like a legit spy.
63:43Uh you're all good. You're free to go.
63:46There's no cop on the beat anymore.
63:50Just in time.
63:53Uh what is that? April 11th, 2025. Paula White Kaine interviews Benjamin Netanyahu on Dayar TV, a Christian Zionist network that broadcasts from Israel. During the interview, she proclaims that Christians must visit Israel in order to go to heaven. If you don't know about Dayar, oh boy, there's a whole rabbit hole. You can go down on YouTube. You can look it up in the news.
64:16You can read about it. Dayar is one of the biggest mega churches in America.
64:21And like a lot of the other megaurches, they've got this all sorts of wild [ __ ] like scandals. But it it's like literally reality TV just the most pathetic, evil, spineless, snaky humans all got together and had a family and then that family was in charge of one of the biggest mega churches in America. And it's just the most mind-blowingly idiotic and amoral and uncchristian thing you could ever come up with. Um I mean the larger date uh scandals around >> [snorts] >> um >> this whole network live >> I couldn't agree with more I've been >> Paula White Donald Trump's faith adviser is her own whole can of worms here
65:13>> since about 1986 it made the Bible in so many ways come alive but I fell in love with the people with the culture with the nation um I took my children and my grandchildren right before the October the horrific um October 7th attack and we embedded oursel a good friend was having a bar mitzvah. We embedded oursel within the orthodox community and had Shabbach together and ate together and fellowship together, studied the Torah together, went all over Israel and it was one of the most memorable best times that we have had as a family and so we are so grateful. I encourage Christians all over the world. You must make your
65:54journey to Israel.
65:57>> Listen to Paul.
65:58>> I I say it will be the best.
66:00>> We will welcome you.
66:01>> Like it might spit on you a few times, but we'll welcome you, right? I mean, they only spit on Brandon Tatum once. It was like that was so kind of them. Like Brandon was just really overwhelmed with how kind that was of them to only spit on him once. Nazareth and the Sea of Galilee and all the places that you hear about. They're not somewhere >> Yeah.
66:24>> remote. They're real places. They're very actually very close to each other.
66:28So, you can actually see where the Bible happened. You can actually see where it happened >> and they're remnants, too. I mean there they're churches you know there there's >> and you know when the original Zionists were starting talking about the Zionist idea the Zionist plan originally a lot of them were saying we should go do it in South America and they were throwing around different ideas and then it kind of came up that you know doing it in Palestine would be pretty good because there would be this whole religious narrative that we could play off of and that would help get Jews to come and you
67:02know start this whole Zionist state thing and that's a large part of why it wound up being in Palestine.
67:08>> Uh a church right in the Sea of Galilee where Jesus preached.
67:13>> Oh yeah.
67:14>> Uh in Kaepernau. Uh it's there. It's standing there. You can stand exactly where Jesus stood. You can walk in the footsteps of Jesus.
67:22>> See, I'll I'll just >> and the Hebrew kings, >> the pilgrims, >> and the everywhere and the prophets, all the prophets that you know, Jeremiah, Isaiah, you know, >> it's it's so life transforming. Except remember that as far as I'm aware, the Jewish religion believes that Jesus was a heretic that totally sacrileged God and was not not not good. And like where is he now according to them?
67:48>> I love going up.
67:49>> But Benjamin Netanyahu is not religious anyways. He doesn't give a [ __ ] He's just trying to hold on to power. So you know >> to Shiloh this past time where Hannah prayed and just I mean just meditating there and seeing just the richness of the Bible in its entirety. it makes everything make sense. And now the archaeological um things that have been discovered and the findings that are still happening um really give people such an education that I'll be honest, they will not get over here in America at 30 minutes in a church or an hour to church service. They certainly won't get it in the universities over here. Wow.
68:20>> It's almost I say as a Christian, it should be mandated to go to Israel before you get to heaven.
68:26>> Whoa.
68:28I was starting to wonder if she would actually say it or if I was getting click baited right here.
68:34That's pretty wild because like let's be clear, I'm not super into like the religion of Christianity. Um, as in the establishment, the the organization, the government of Christianity, so to speak.
68:50But like in my interactions with Christians of all forms, there's certain things that are like a little more sacrilegious than others.
68:57And that's like making claims as though you were God or you were Jesus. Like proclaiming to speak for God and for Jesus is like pretty bold making claim.
69:09I mean she's she was suggesting it not claiming it to be true, I guess. But that's a little awkward.
69:16But what do I know? I mean I'm like I'm no expert.
69:19>> [snorts] >> Um, all right. Fast forward July 20th.
69:22The Israeli Foreign Ministry announces a program to send 550 influencers on fully paid trips to Israel by year's end with the goal of creating a cadre of sympathetic social media voices. Right?
69:34And we all remember this. The initiative will bring 16 US-based influencers under the age of 30, each with hundreds of thousands to millions of followers to counter what the ministry sees as a decline in pro-Israel sentiment among younger Americans.
69:48Right? this included. So, the CCPI is the uh oh, I forget. We'll we'll come back to it in a second and find what that stands for. [snorts] Um, they hold a private meeting to counter the woke right defamation of Israel, targeting influencers like Theo Vaughn, Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, Marjorie Taylor Green, and Steve Bannon.
70:12I'll work harder so that I'm on the list next time. And attendees included all of these people.
70:18Yay Netanyahu, Benjamin Netanyahu's son who's been hiding in Israel or sorry, hiding in Florida the entire time there's been this war going on over there. [clears throat] And then we get to August and Bill Aman hosts this meeting in the Hamptons to discuss support for Israel with influencers including Charlie Kirk, Seth Dylan, CJ Pearson, etc., etc. Savior de Rouso, Emily Saves America, you know, all of these shills.
70:43had a great meeting with US ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabe at the US embassy in Jerusalem. Cam Higgby, Xavier, all of them. Shills. Shills all around. Right.
70:55So, just remember this is happening now in this environment where they have multiplied the budget for Hosbra by 20.
71:03They've set up a whole bunch of new foundations. They they were checking out to see what are the FAR regulations and how do we skirt them? If we start paying a bunch of influencers, are they all going to have to register? What's the deal? Then Pam Bondi comes in and is like, "Don't worry, I'll just kill that whole task force. It's all gone. Open season." And as soon as that happens, we start to get all these new organizations popping up and all this new money is flooding in and all these new influencers are getting paid and going on trips and getting talking points, right? And Charlie Kirk is right in the
71:35middle of all that.
71:38and he's in the middle of it as a liaison to the youth of America and he's seeing how young people feel about the whole thing and it's not going too hot and we all know where that led. It led to this text thread on September 8th, 2025.
71:57Jewish donors play into all the stereotypes. I cannot and will not be bullied like this, leaving me no choice but to leave the pro-Israel cause. And according to Josh Hammer, I think that the idea is that that is him joking around.
72:16I think that Josh was trying to claim that he was just kidding. He wasn't being serious. He was just shooting the [ __ ] because Charlie Kirk totally just not seriously texts a whole bunch of Jewish donors that are super militant about Israel that will [ __ ] tear you to shreds and pull their funding from you if you say something even remotely like a tenth of that. I'm sure that Charlie just jokingly throws out statements like no choice but to leave the pro-Israel cause. Totally a joke, Josh. Right.
72:56So, a little placeholder here in the middle, the assassination of Charlie Kirk, which we're not going to go into the depth on right now. Oh, yeah. One other thing, though. It's important to note that Charlie wasn't just sending this text message, which is now confirmed as true. But now we have like three sources reporting that they have like a total of six sources so to speak that Charlie was saying to his close confidants that he was worried that Israel would try to kill him if he turned on them. Right? Harrison reported on it a month before the before the murder and he had one source. Candace
73:32has now reported on it saying that she has three different sources that have said that and she said that two of those sources have it in writing apparently.
73:40Hopefully we get that released and Max Blumenthal has also reported on that with at least one source if not up to five. Right. So that's the kind of media environment that we're in right now where the top Israel shill is telling his friends that he's afraid they're going to [ __ ] kill him if he turns on them. He's having his donors pulled from him in this kind of an environment.
74:07These guys are getting paid and flying to Israel, sticking things down the back of their throats and [ __ ] you know, like this is the storm heating [snorts] up.
74:19And then pow, we all know what happens. September 10th, 2025.
Read the essay version →